A potato slice in fresh water can gain mass, while a matching slice in very salty water can lose mass. So how does osmosis work if water molecules are free to cross a cell membrane in either direction? The scale gives you a clue, but it doesn't count every crossing. It records the result after water entering and water leaving have both had their effects.
Water molecules are in constant thermal motion. A cell's plasma membrane separates the fluid inside the cell from the fluid outside it. The membrane lets water cross but restricts the passage of many dissolved substances. Water can pass directly through the membrane's lipid bilayer or through water channels called aquaporins. Neither route acts like a one-way door.
Imagine counting crossings at one membrane during a short interval. In a made-up tally, 120 water molecules cross into the cell and 100 cross out. The cell gains 20, not 120. If you measure only the change in the amount of water inside, you get the difference between the two counts. That difference is the net movement.
Now suppose the counts are equal. No water accumulates on either side, but molecules are still crossing. This is dynamic equilibrium: the amounts stay steady even though individual molecules keep moving. A still reading on a scale doesn't mean the water molecules have stopped moving. For another look at what makes a membrane selectively permeable, see OpenStax's explanation of passive transport.
Use plain water with no added salt as the fresh water in this comparison. Potato cells contain dissolved substances such as sugars and ions. If you start with distilled water outside the tissue, the surrounding liquid has fewer dissolved particles than the cell fluid. This difference favors water entry. More water crosses inward than outward, even though outward crossings continue.
As water enters a living potato cell, its growing contents press against the cell wall. The wall resists expansion, and pressure builds inside the cell. This pressure, called turgor pressure, helps make the tissue firm. The cell wall provides mechanical support; the plasma membrane is the barrier that controls which substances can cross readily.
Pressure also explains why the cell doesn't keep gaining water indefinitely. As pressure inside rises, it increasingly opposes net entry. In plant biology, water potential accounts for the effects of both dissolved substances and pressure. Dissolved substances lower water potential, while pressure like the kind that builds inside a firm plant cell raises it. Net movement is from higher to lower water potential. If the two sides reach the same water potential, the crossing rates balance even though the solute concentrations can still differ.
Dissolving salt in the surrounding water lowers its water potential. If it falls below the water potential inside the potato cells, outward crossings outnumber inward crossings. The cells lose water, their turgor pressure drops, and the slice can become more flexible. After blotting, it can also weigh less than it did before soaking.
The word enough matters. Adding a small amount of salt doesn't guarantee that a potato slice will lose mass. A weak salt solution can still have a higher water potential than the tissue at the start, in which case the slice can gain water. An intermediate solution may produce little measurable change. The label on the cup tells you what you added, not which direction water will move overall.
Think about what happens at the moment you move a slice from plain water into a strong salt solution. The new surroundings change the balance of crossings. They don't give every water molecule a new direction. Some molecules outside the cells will still enter after the transfer, just as some molecules inside were leaving while the slice was in plain water.
Cut matching slices from the same potato and measure their starting masses. Put one slice in plain water and another in a solution made by dissolving table salt in water. Use equal liquid volumes and keep the slices fully submerged for the same length of time at the same temperature. If you have enough potato, use several slices in each condition so that one unusual piece doesn't determine the result.
Blot each slice gently and consistently before the final weighing. Droplets clinging to the surface would add mass even if they never entered a cell. Compare the slices using percentage mass change, especially if their starting masses differ a little:
Percentage mass change = 100 × (final mass − starting mass) / starting mass
A slice that starts at 10.0 grams and finishes at 10.5 grams has gained 5 percent. One that starts at 10.0 grams and finishes at 9.5 grams has lost 5 percent. These are example calculations, not results to expect from every potato. A scale weighs the whole piece, including damaged cells and liquid between cells. It doesn't measure the rate of water crossing any one membrane. Look for a consistent pattern across slices rather than treating a single reading as a count of molecular events.
Suppose a slice comes out of a salt solution with no detectable mass change. One possible explanation is that inward and outward water movement approximately balanced. Another is that the net change was too small for the scale to detect. With just a starting and a final mass, you also can't tell whether the mass stayed steady during the entire soak. You can say that the slice showed no measurable overall change, but you can't say that no water crossed its cell membranes.
Try drawing two arrows across a cell membrane. Make the inward arrow longer for net entry, the outward arrow longer for net loss, and the arrows equal for balanced exchange. Label the arrows as rates of crossing, not as the amounts of water on each side. For more ways to practice interpreting biological evidence, see the IBioC training and practice problems or browse the Biology Explained articles.
Does osmosis stop at equilibrium?
Net water movement stops, but individual water molecules still cross the membrane. On average, as many cross in one direction as in the other.
Will any amount of salt make a potato slice lose mass?
No. The salt solution must lower the water potential outside the cells below the water potential inside them to cause net water loss.
Why blot the potato before weighing it?
Blotting removes surface droplets that would otherwise add to the reading. Use the same gentle blotting method for every slice.
About the International Biology Competition: an online biology competition for high school students from around the world. How the rounds work