Why Does Energy Decrease Up the Food Chain?

Blog › Biology Explained

· by Julia Berens · 4 min read

Close-up of a bright green frog resting on a dark green leaf, with golden-brown eyes and softly blurred foliage behind it.

A caterpillar bites into a leaf, and later a bird eats the caterpillar. The bird can get chemical energy from the caterpillar's tissues, but it cannot get all the energy that was in the leaf. So why does energy decrease up the food chain? Only part of the chemical energy in the caterpillar's meal is retained in new body material. Some leaves the caterpillar in waste, and some is transferred to the surroundings as heat as the caterpillar lives and grows.

Start with the bite, not the whole leaf

A trophic level is a feeding position. In this example, the plant is the producer, the caterpillar is the primary consumer, and the bird feeding on the caterpillar is a secondary consumer. The plant uses light energy to make sugars through photosynthesis. Some of the chemical energy is retained in the leaf's organic compounds. The caterpillar takes in some of that energy when it eats the leaf.

Start your account at the caterpillar's mouth. Any piece of leaf still attached to the plant does not count as part of the meal. That piece could be eaten later or fall to the ground and enter a different feeding pathway. It is not the same as waste: uneaten leaf material never entered the caterpillar, while feces contain material that passed through its gut.

Track what the gut absorbs and what it leaves behind

Digestion breaks down some large food molecules into smaller ones. For example, proteins can be broken down into amino acids that the caterpillar can absorb. But swallowing a leaf does not mean absorbing everything in it. Some food material passes through the gut without being absorbed and leaves in feces. Caterpillar droppings are called frass.

Frass still contains organic material with chemical energy. Microbes can break down some of that material and use it for their own growth and respiration. That energy has not been destroyed or released entirely as heat by the caterpillar. It has left the plant-to-caterpillar-to-bird pathway and entered a pathway that begins with dead organic matter. Waste can also include substances excreted after food has been absorbed and processed, so not every bit of waste is simply undigested leaf.

Why does energy decrease up the food chain?

Once nutrients are absorbed, the caterpillar can use them in different ways. It can use amino acids to build proteins in growing tissues, for instance, or retain chemical energy in fat reserves. The added tissues and reserves count as new biomass, meaning new body material. If a bird eats that material, it can obtain some of the chemical energy retained there. The bird will not absorb everything it eats or retain everything it absorbs, either.

The caterpillar also breaks down fuel molecules in cellular respiration. Its cells capture some of the released energy in ATP, which helps power tasks such as muscle contraction, transport across cell membranes, and the building of proteins. Heat is released during respiration and as cells use energy to do work. A bird can eat the caterpillar's muscle, but it cannot recover the energy that already warmed the surroundings while that muscle moved.

Growth itself has an energy cost. Building a protein uses energy, and the finished protein also contains chemical energy. Those are two different entries in the account: energy transferred as heat during the work of building tissue is not the energy retained in the tissue. The distinction matters even if the caterpillar barely moves. A resting animal still uses energy to keep its cells functioning.

Balance a caterpillar's energy budget

Suppose a caterpillar eats leaf material containing 100 joules of chemical energy. Use these made-up values to track where that energy goes over a feeding and growth period. They are not measurements or a prediction for a particular species.

DestinationEnergyWhat that means
Waste40 joulesChemical energy leaves in feces and other waste.
Heat45 joulesEnergy is transferred to the surroundings as the caterpillar carries out life processes.
New biomass15 joulesChemical energy is retained in added tissue and reserves.

The three entries add up to 100 joules. Of the energy in the leaf material eaten, 15 percent ends up in new caterpillar biomass in this example. That does not mean a bird adds 15 joules to its own body. Even if the bird eats all the new material, it will leave some energy in waste and transfer some to the surroundings as heat. And if it eats the whole caterpillar, its meal will include older tissue built from earlier meals, which is outside this particular budget.

Check the denominator before calling a percentage a transfer efficiency. Here, the starting amount is energy in the leaf material eaten, not all the new biomass the plant produced. A comparison between trophic levels uses the energy in new biomass produced at each level over the same area and time. Uneaten plant material can make those percentages different. Neither calculation requires assuming that exactly 10 percent always passes to the next level. OpenStax's explanation of energy flow through ecosystems distinguishes these kinds of efficiency.

Practice tracking energy with a diagram

Draw a box for the caterpillar and an incoming arrow labeled “energy in leaf material eaten.” Give the box separate arrows for heat and waste, and write “new biomass” inside it. Now draw a bird and connect it to the new biomass, not to the original leaf meal. If you want to show what happens to frass, draw a separate arrow from waste to decomposers. Keep every label in units of energy, such as joules, rather than switching to grams halfway through.

For more ways to work with data, see our guide to reading biology graphs. For IBioC practice, use the same habit of labeling inputs and outputs when you work through quantitative questions from the training and practice problems.

Frequently asked questions

Is energy in caterpillar poop lost as heat?
No. Frass still contains chemical energy that organisms such as bacteria and fungi can use. Heat is a separate output in the caterpillar's energy budget.

Does exactly 10 percent of energy always pass to the next level?
No. The fraction varies with how much biomass is eaten, how much of the food is absorbed, and how much energy the consumer retains as new biomass.

Does a caterpillar release heat even when it is resting?
Yes. Its cells still carry out respiration and use energy to maintain basic functions, so some energy is transferred to the surroundings as heat.

About the International Biology Competition: an online biology competition for high school students from around the world. How the rounds work

Written by Julia Berens, Social Media Assistant of the IBioC team.

More articles

All articles