How to Solve Pedigree Problems by Tracking Alleles

Blog › Exam Preparation

· by Julia Berens · 4 min read

When you are learning how to solve pedigree problems, start with one child rather than the shape of the whole family tree. Pick an inheritance pattern, write down what the child would have to inherit, and check whether each parent could supply the required allele. One impossible transmission rules out the pattern under the question’s assumptions. One possible transmission only keeps it in the running.

How to solve pedigree problems one allele at a time

Read the pedigree’s key first. In a typical exam diagram, a shaded symbol marks a person who expresses the trait. An unshaded symbol does not automatically tell you the person’s genotype: someone who does not express a recessive trait can still carry the allele for it.

Use the assumptions in the question. The examples here use a single gene, complete penetrance, and no new mutations. Complete penetrance means that a person with a genotype that causes the trait shows it. In the standard XX and XY model used here, a father passes his X chromosome to each daughter and his Y chromosome to each son. A mother passes one of her X chromosomes to each child. For an autosomal gene, each child receives one allele from each parent. MedlinePlus Genetics explains these inheritance patterns and illustrates how they run in families.

Test one pattern at a time. Give each person the genotypes that could match their shading, then narrow those choices using the parent-child links. A pattern fits only if you can give every person one genotype that works throughout the pedigree. You cannot make a parent a carrier for one child and then assign that same parent a noncarrier genotype for another.

Use an affected child to test both parents

Suppose two unaffected parents have an affected son. Start with autosomal dominant inheritance. Let D be the dominant allele that causes the trait and d the other allele. Both unaffected parents must be dd. Neither can supply D, so the son cannot be affected under this model.

Now try autosomal recessive inheritance. Let r be the recessive allele that causes the trait and R the other allele. The affected son must be rr. He needs one r from each parent. Both parents are unaffected, so each must be Rr. That assignment works.

X-linked recessive inheritance works too. Write the recessive allele as Xr and the other allele as XR. The son can be XrY if his unaffected mother is XRXr. His unaffected father is XRY and supplies the Y, not an allele at this X-linked gene. X-linked dominant inheritance does not fit: the son’s X comes from his unaffected mother, who cannot carry the dominant allele without showing the trait under these assumptions.

Now change just one detail: the affected child is a daughter. Autosomal recessive still works with two Rr parents. But under X-linked recessive inheritance, an affected daughter needs Xr from both parents. Her unaffected father can give her only XR. That specific transmission rules out the X-linked recessive model.

Trace the chromosome instead of matching the shading

An affected father and an affected son do not automatically rule out X-linked inheritance. They share a phenotype, but that does not mean the son received the allele from his father. Under X-linked recessive inheritance, an affected father (XrY) and an unaffected carrier mother (XRXr) can have an affected son. The son gets Y from his father and Xr from his mother.

For a sharper test of X-linked dominant inheritance, look at the affected father’s daughters. If his genotype is XDY, every daughter receives XD from him and must show the trait under complete penetrance. Even one unaffected daughter rules out that model. The same father-daughter pair can fit autosomal dominant inheritance: a Dd father can pass d to a daughter, and if she also gets d from her mother, she is unaffected.

Keep the distinction clear in your written answer. “The father and son are both affected” describes the diagram. “The son could not have received his father’s X chromosome” explains a transmission constraint. Only the second statement tells you what the chromosome route allows.

Keep every model that fits a small pedigree

Return to the two unaffected parents and their affected son. Suppose the family also has an unaffected daughter. Under autosomal recessive inheritance, two Rr parents can have an rr son and an Rr or RR daughter. Under X-linked recessive inheritance, an XRXr mother and an XRY father can have an XrY son and an unaffected daughter who is either XRXR or XRXr. The extra sibling does not settle the question.

Nor does the fact that the only affected child is male. Autosomal recessive inheritance can affect sons and daughters, but it does not require an affected child of each sex in a particular family. Punnett square probabilities describe possible outcomes for each child, not a quota that siblings must fill. If two models account for everybody and the question gives you no other constraints, name both. If it asks which is possible, one valid genotype assignment proves that a model qualifies. It does not prove that the model is unique.

Write the allele evidence in your exam answer

For more work on explaining your reasoning, see the IBioC training and practice problems and exam preparation articles.

A useful final check is to take your proposed genotypes and read the pedigree from parent to child. For each child, point to the parent who could supply each relevant allele. Write the exact step that fails when you reject a model. For example: “X-linked recessive inheritance does not fit because the affected daughter would need Xr from her father, but her unaffected father has only XR to pass to her.”

Frequently asked questions

Does a trait that skips a generation have to be recessive?
A gap alone is not enough. Under a single-gene model with complete penetrance and no new mutations, the stronger clue is an affected child with two unaffected parents, which rules out the usual autosomal dominant and X-linked dominant models.

Can an unaffected person carry a recessive allele?
Yes. An unaffected person with an autosomal recessive allele and a second allele that prevents the trait from appearing can pass the recessive allele to a child.

What if two inheritance patterns fit?
If the question asks you to decide from the pedigree alone, name both and give a consistent genotype assignment for each. A compatible pattern is not necessarily the only one.

About the International Biology Competition: an online biology competition for high school students from around the world. How the rounds work

Written by Julia Berens, Social Media Assistant of the IBioC team.

More articles

All articles